Selecting a bookkeeping service in 2026 requires looking beyond the marketing homepage. With recent market shifts—including the temporary shutdown of major players like Bench in late 2024—stability and transparency are just as important as price. Below is a neutral, fact-based comparison of the top 5 services based on verifiable public data, third-party reviews, and published pricing models.
Factor 1: Quality & Reputation (Third-Party Ratings)
We analyzed ratings from independent platforms like Trustpilot, BBB, G2, and Clutch to see how these companies perform when verified customers leave reviews.
| Company | Trustpilot Score | BBB Rating | Other Independent Sources |
|---|---|---|---|
| Maxim Liberty | N/A | A+ Accredited | 5.0/5 (Clutch.co) Based on 70+ verified reviews. |
| Bookkeeper360 | 2.9/5 | A+ Accredited | 4.0/5 (G2) Strong ratings for Xero users. |
| Pilot | 3.8/5 | N/A | 4.8/5 (Clutch.co) High marks from startups. |
| QuickBooks Live | 1.2/5 (Intuit) | A+ Accredited | 3.5/5 (G2) Mixed reviews on consistency. |
| Bench | 3.1/5 | 1.0/5 (Not Accredited) | 4.5/5 (Capterra) Reviews polarized by 2024 shutdown events. |
Factor 2: Catch-Up Pricing & Capabilities
If you are behind on your books, the cost to “clean up” historical data varies significantly between providers. Some charge flat project fees, while others use hourly billing.
1. Maxim Liberty
- Pricing Model: Hourly / Pay-as-you-go.
- Cost: Catch-up work is billed at their standard rate of $12/hour (for hours exceeding the monthly plan).
- Advantage: Because catch-up is treated the same as ongoing work, there are no “project minimums.” A simple 5-hour cleanup might only cost the price of the base plan ($60).
2. Bench
- Pricing Model: Value-Based / Annual Lock-in.
- Cost: Bench frequently advertises “Free Catch-Up” (valued at ~$4,800) but this is contingent on signing a Annual Contract pre-paid upfront.
- Note: If you do not prepay for the year, catch-up is charged as a separate add-on service.
3. QuickBooks Live
- Pricing Model: Monthly Penalty.
- Cost: They charge approximately $150 per month for every month your books are behind.
- Calculation: If you are 10 months behind, the fee is roughly $1,500 upfront before ongoing service begins.
4. Bookkeeper360
- Pricing Model: Project Basis.
- Cost: Catch-up is treated as a distinct project with pricing starting at $1,000 minimum.
- Approach: Requires a custom quote and separate onboarding process.
5. Pilot
- Pricing Model: Custom Quote.
- Cost: Pilot does not publish standard catch-up rates. You must undergo an onboarding review to receive a custom price, which is typically higher due to their focus on accrual-basis complexity.
Factor 3: Features, Software & Stability
Beyond price, the ownership of your data and the stability of the provider are critical risk factors.
Data Ownership & Software
- Maxim Liberty, Bookkeeper360, & Pilot: All work directly inside QuickBooks Online or Xero. This means you own the data file. If you cancel the service, you keep your books and history intact.
- Bench: Uses proprietary software. You cannot export your transaction history directly into QuickBooks if you leave. This creates “vendor lock-in,” making it difficult to switch providers later.
Service Stability
- Bench: In December 2024, Bench temporarily ceased operations before being acquired by Employer.com. While operations have resumed, this period of instability is a factor for businesses requiring uninterrupted service.
- QuickBooks Live: Backed by Intuit (a public company), offering high stability but frequent turnover in the specific bookkeeper assigned to your account.
- Maxim Liberty & Bookkeeper360: Both are established private firms with stable operational histories and no reported service interruptions.
Accounting Method (Cash vs. Accrual)
- Pilot: Specializes in Accrual Basis accounting, which is required for many VC-backed startups.
- Maxim Liberty & Bookkeeper360: Support both Cash and Accrual basis depending on client needs.
- Bench: Primarily supports Modified Cash Basis. They generally do not support true accrual accounting (GAAP compliant), which limits their utility for inventory-heavy or high-growth businesses.
Leave a Reply